Hiring From Competitors? You Could Be One Lawsuit Away from a Legal Nightmare

Posted on by

Paul Curwell

6–9 minutes

Key Points: When hiring talent from competitors, IP contamination is a serious issue that businesses need to be aware of.

  • Hiring from competitors can expose your business to trade secret theft accusations, IP contamination, and legal battles.
  • Employees bringing proprietary knowledge may fast-track product development—but also invite lawsuits and reputational damage.
  • Companies must implement robust safeguards like due diligence, clear policies, and compliance monitoring to avoid costly mistakes.

Let’s be real. Hiring someone from your competitor can feel like finding a golden ticket: instant industry expertise, insider knowledge, and maybe even a shortcut to commercial success. But before you pop the champagne, you need to ask yourself one question—is it worth the risk?

Hiring from competitors opens the door to trade secret theft and IP contamination, and trust me, it can end in a full-blown legal disaster. I’ve seen it myself, when an ‘almost patent ready’ research team left for a competitor, only to lead to a years’ long legal dispute.

Still unconvinced? Many companies find themselves locked in a battle over trade secrets that could cost millions. We’re talking about lawsuits, reputational damage, and legal fees that most businesses can’t afford, especially if you’re just starting out.

Unfortunately, when it comes to IP theft, it doesn’t matter if you were trying to play fair—the courts will still come knocking. So before you make that tempting job offer to a new candidate, let’s dig into why hiring from competitors can backfire—and what you can do to protect your business from a lawsuit.

The Ugly Truth: Risks of Hiring From Competitors

It’s not just about bringing someone on board with great skills—it’s about what they bring with them. Spoiler alert: It could be someone else’s trade secrets. Here’s how that can go south:

1. Trade Secret Misappropriation Accusations

Okay, so maybe you’re not actively stealing trade secrets. But what if your new hire is? If they bring over confidential files, customer lists, or proprietary research, you could face accusations of misappropriation—and that’s a legal nightmare waiting to happen.

Take one case recently settled in the US courts: The MedTech plaintiff accused the defendent of allegedly using stolen trade secrets to fast-track their product development (see below for Court record). The U.S. District Court of Central California found in favour of the plaintiff in 2024, ordering the three defendents to make up for the losses. That’s millions of dollars in legal fees and endless bad press, not to mention stress and anxiety for all involved. All for what?

2. The Discovery Phase: Your Secrets Exposed

Now, let’s talk about discovery in lawsuits. When things hit the fan, courts can force you to turn over sensitive internal documents. Imagine your competitors getting access to your inner workings—for free. What a nightmare!

Not all legal risks come from intentional acts. Sometimes, a new hire might be struggling to keep up, and they bring proprietary knowledge from their previous employer to cover up their lack of skills, hoping not to get found out.

Even if it’s totally unintentional, your company could still be on the hook. The courts don’t care about your good intentions—they’ll care about the fact that you have stolen IP in your possession.

4. Corporate Espionage Anyone?

Here’s where things get really dirty. Some companies actually seek out employees from their competitors to extract trade secrets. If you’re actively hiring to gain a strategic edge, you’re playing with fire. And if you get caught, the penalties are severe: fines, injunctions, and irreparable reputational damage. It’s industrial espionage at its finest—and it’s a game you don’t want to play.

5. Innocent IP Contamination: Blurred Lines

Let’s say you hire an R&D expert or an engineer with years of experience. They come in with great credentials—but are they carrying proprietary knowledge with them? The line between public knowledge and trade secrets is thin. One little slip-up, and suddenly, you’re dealing with IP contamination that could cost you big time. Innocent mistakes can land you in hot water—unfortunately, aren’t forgiving.

6. The “Harmless” Spreadsheet That Could Get You Sued

Sometimes, it’s not the big stuff. It’s the small stuff that gets you caught. An employee transfers an Excel file from their previous employer’s server to yours. Seems harmless, right? Well, if that file contains proprietary data—you’re responsible.

7. Non-Compete Breaches: Oops, You Did It Again

Let’s not forget about the non-compete and confidentiality agreements employees sign. If your new hire is bound by these agreements, you could be violating them just by hiring them. Breaching these agreements opens up a whole can of legal worms. In the case referenced above, the defendants allegedly breached confidentiality clauses, and both the employee and the company were dragged through the legal mud.

image of an employee slipping an envelope marked 'trade secrets' into a bag
image of an employee slipping an envelope marked ‘trade secrets’ into a bag

So, now that you know the risks, here’s the big question: How can you hire talent without setting yourself up for a lawsuit?

1. Implement Bulletproof Security Protocols

Don’t wait until after the hire to protect your business. Get your security team involved in the hiring process. Make sure data management policies are airtight, and prevent any transfer of proprietary data—whether intentional or accidental. If your new hire brings over sensitive files, they shouldn’t even make it onto your servers.

Startup Sabotage: A Trade Secret Theft Case Study & How to Protect Your Company

2. Do Your Homework: Due Diligence is Key

Before you sign that offer letter, do a deep dive into the candidate’s previous employment agreements. Look for any potential red flags. Ask questions about their previous job, but don’t solicit confidential information. The goal is to understand their obligations—not to ask them to break their confidentiality.

3. Set Clear Expectations (And Have Them Sign It)

From day one, be crystal clear with your new hire: “You cannot bring any proprietary information from your old employer.” Get them to sign an agreement acknowledging this. This ensures there’s no ambiguity about the rules.

4. Secure Onboarding: Make It Foolproof

Make sure your onboarding process includes training on intellectual property and data security. Set access to sensitive data based on need-to-know principles—because just because someone can access it doesn’t mean they should. And check that they’ve returned all confidential data to their previous employer before starting with you.

5. Teach Employees the Difference Between Expertise and Trade Secrets

Help your employees understand the difference between public knowledge and trade secrets. Training them on this distinction could save you from costly mistakes. When in doubt—don’t share it.

6. Use Technology to Monitor and Protect

In 2025, there’s no excuse for not having Data Loss Prevention (DLP) tools in place. Regular audits, exit interviews, and compliance monitoring should be standard. If you’re not keeping track, you’re asking for trouble.

The Bottom Line: Hire Smart, Protect Your Business

Hiring from competitors can be an amazing strategic move—but only if you do it the right way. Don’t let the allure of quick talent cloud your judgment. If you’re not careful, a single wrong hire could lead to a lawsuit that costs millions.

So, let me ask you: Are you ready to hire the next big thing—or are you setting yourself up for a legal nightmare?

What steps are you taking to protect your business from IP contamination and trade secret theft? Drop your thoughts below. Let’s chat!

84-microventionDownload

Further Reading:

DISCLAIMER: All information presented on paulcurwell.com is intended for general information purposes only. The content of paulcurwell.com should not be considered legal or any other form of advice or opinion on any specific facts or circumstances. Readers should consult their own advisers experts or lawyers on any specific questions they may have. Any reliance placed upon paulcurwell.com is strictly at the reader’s own risk. The views expressed by the authors are entirely their own and do not represent the views of, nor are they endorsed by, their respective employers. Refer here for full disclaimer.